And now, a listing of the nominees, ordered by how much I liked them.
This was the only nominee that I didn't think deserved its nomination. While Viola Davis turned in a stunning performance, the majority of this film fell flat, due to an inability to embrace the change in medium from stage to screen. However, I don't think I would have liked it any better in its original stage format. The main character was terrible to his family, and yet the ending seemed to want you to remember him fondly, without ever having shown you a good reason why you should.
#8. Hidden Figures
I enjoyed this story of the women behind the US space launches in the 1960s, although I would have liked it more if the screenplay hadn't Hollywood-ized history to make things more dramatic. I especially liked the story of Mary Jackson, and her efforts to break into the predominantly white- and male-dominated profession of engineering. The only reason this is towards the bottom of my list is because there were so many good movies in this year's nominations.
#7. Hacksaw Ridge
I like war movies quite a bit, and we saw this one in theaters on opening weekend. The battle scenes in this were difficult to watch (though not quite as hard as the opening of Saving Private Ryan), but I think it's occasionally necessary to remember what has been sacrificed in service of our nation, and movies like this help with that. The treatment of religion was also well handled, and Andrew Garfield was perfect in his role.
#6. Moonlight
I know this movie won Best Picture, and artistically, it was very well done (although I'm not quite sure about the ending, or lack thereof). The acting was also excellent, and the cinematography was beautiful. I also liked the way the story was structured, and I can see why it won, even if I didn't enjoy it quite as much as some of the other nominees.
#5. Hell or High Water
This was very much a modern-day Western, and watching it made me miss the open landscape and big sky of Oklahoma and Texas. It has a shorter run time, but that works well, because things move at just the right pace. The characters and their various interactions are fascinating, the action is interspersed nicely throughout the movie, and every scene feels necessary to the narrative.
#4. Manchester by the Sea
If I were going to give a Best Picture award based solely on the quality of the movie and not on my enjoyment of it, this would be the nominee that I would vote for. Casey Affleck completely deserved his Best Actor win, and this movie haunted me for weeks after I watched it. It made me think a lot about hope, and the lack thereof, and the source of true hope, and I actually ended up being encouraged by what was honestly a fairly depressing movie.
#3. Lion
As someone with an adopted brother from another country, this movie hit home in ways that I didn't expect. It was also based on an incredible true story, and I always get emotional over stories about family to begin with. I managed to stay fairly emotionally stable right up until the very end, and then lost it at a couple of the details revealed in the text onscreen.
#2. Arrival
An alien first contact movie that isn't really about the aliens at all, this was a beautiful movie. I sadly missed out on seeing it in theaters, but even on the small screen the cinematography was lovely, and the story itself was wonderful. I've read a few articles about how the language you speak affects the way you think about things, and the way this movie integrates that idea makes for a powerful ending.
#1. La La Land
I love this movie. The cinematography is gorgeous, there's a wonderful balance between the suspension of reality and the recognition of it, and the nods to old Hollywood are everywhere. It's simultaneously a celebration and critique of the classic films that inspired it, and Mia and Sebastian are as close as we're going to get nowadays to an iconic film couple, even if their story isn't quite the Hollywood fairy tale you might expect.

.png)


.png)

.png)
